Sunday, July 27, 2008

Portable Classrooms in the APS

When school districts are flush with cash,
and they need to build a school,
they build a brick and mortar monument to themselves and their endeavor.

In lean times, when districts need to build a school,
they build a gymnasium, cafeteria, and a library of brick and mortar, and everyone else goes to a portable.

APS portable classrooms are poorly kept, dilapidated and generally regarded as an insult to those students and adults who work in them. They are not considered worthy even, of fire safety inspections.


They needn't be. It is an administrative failure that has caused the dilapidation of portable classrooms in the APS.

Correctly done;

  • Portables are attractive and comfortable and safe
  • They create community among those who work in them.
  • They are efficient to heat and cool.
  • They are "easy" to move around, as schools need to accommodate more or fewer students.
  • The are repairable; they can be refurbished for ever.

The truth is that if you sit in a portable classroom, you wouldn't know you were in one,

except that the roof is lower, the windows are small,
and dirty, and they are covered with heavy metal grates.
(not unlike the windows in most prisons)

I submit that the APS is a school district in lean times,
and times which are certain to become leaner.

And if we weren't spending a hundred and fifty million dollars on a single high school,

and a million dollars on an unnecessary new boardroom, and who knows how many millions in the unending renovation of the twin towers at 6400 Uptown Blvd;

the portable classrooms in the APS would not be poorly kept,
dilapidated and generally regarded as an insult to those
students and adults who work in them.

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

If one were to contact the manufacturers of portables, they would find that portables have a very limited lifespan, and they are not made to be "repairable". Sometimes their lifespan is made to be only 3 years. Few are made to last more than 6 or 7 years.
Across the country portables are in disrepair, w/ holes in the floor, and sometmes no AC or heat.
Admin gambles that the portable can outllive it's designed "lifespan" because they save money at the expense of student safety. Google florida schools and protables and you will find many horror stories about injuries and problems from old portables still being used.
Portables are an expensive "lease" idea. If you take the expenses of the lees, license and transportation and removal costs of all the portables in 1 school, you will probably find you could have built a small building to house those students for a little bit more $$.
Portables will probably become outlawed stse-by-state eventually. They are a crappy way to admin your budget!

ched macquigg said...

On the other hand, portables could be stick built on site by vocational students, and designed to be broken down for transportation.

The obstacles are not insurmountable,

We don't have to buy steel buildings from people who will only guarantee them for three years.

And shame on the administrators who would buy such trash.